Stacks Image 299

Click on your location to get started:

Not sure which location is closest to you? Click here!

Stacks Image 218
You can also order party trays from our catering menu & have enough for several meals! Please order 24 hours in advance. Call your favorite location between 11am - 2pm or 4pm - 5pm or email us (Indy or Lexington).
Stacks Image 260
Stacks Image 262

Want something to stick in your head? Listen to this!

Stacks Image 292

pizza pie

our cheese pizza starts with all-natural flour for our dough (absolutely no bleach or bromates), california sun-ripened tomatoes and herbs for our sauce, with the finest domestic and italian cheeses... enjoy a smiling teeth combo or choose your own destiny!
8" small 4 slices 6.85
12" medium 8 slices 11.30
16" large 16 slices 15.75
10" gluten-free 8 slices 11.30

small 1.40 | medium 2.00 | large 2.60
Stacks Image 325
Stacks Image 215
most of our menu can be prepared gluten-free
(above: gluten-free margherita & pepperoni pizzas) this symbol • accompanies dishes that cannot be prepared gluten-free. We do not recommend these options to severely gluten-sensitive individuals due to a possibility of cross contact as wheat flour is used in our kitchen

smiling teeth pizza combos

no more than one substitution please (gluten-free pizza combos: medium price)
Stacks Image 72
ultimate warrior (above) sausage, pepperoni, onions, black olives, mushrooms & green peppers sm 9.75 | med 17.25 | lg 25.25
bar 20 • barbecue chicken & sauce, red onions & smoked gouda sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
king of hearts artichoke hearts, mushrooms, bacon, whole black olives & capers sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
Stacks Image 76
sweet lil’ razorback (above) pepperoni, smoked sausage, bacon, with a lil’ basil & garlic sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
cactus delectus yellow & red bell peppers, chorizo, cilantro, jack cheese, (jalapeño optional) sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
panama red shrimp, pesto, red bell peppers, jack cheese, green onions & cilantro sm 10.15 | med 17.60 | lg 25.50
twice baked new potatoes, bacon, green onions, smoked gouda & puccini’s very own buttermilk herb dressing sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
bill (formerly known as steve) hot italian sausage, yellow & red bell peppers, thyme, oregano & parsley sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
shrimp santori shrimp, sesame chili oil, red onions, sun-dried tomatoes & fresh basil sm 10.15 | med 17.60 | lg 25.50
BLT bacon, lettuce & tomatoes with mayo sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
Stacks Image 80
campfire (above) (winner of the best classic pizza in america!) smoked sausage, sweet onion marmalade, gorgonzola & fresh rosemary sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25


Stacks Image 84
margherita fresh tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, oregano & fontina cheese sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
humble pie fresh garlic, fresh basil, sun-dried tomatoes & fontina cheese sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
paparazzi our regular cheese blend plus gorgonzola & ricotta cheese sm 8.75 | med 14.65 | lg 21.25
zorba the pizza spinach, red onions, whole black olives & feta cheese sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25
lean machine about 1/3 the fat of our regular pizza: a thick crushed tomato sauce full of herbs & spices, sprinkled with fresh parmesan & romano cheese sm 6.85 | med 11.30 | lg 15.75
Stacks Image 90
veg-head (above) broccoli, yellow bell peppers, tomato, red onions, black olives, fresh garlic & fontina sm 9.75 | med 17.25 | lg 25.25
bama jam pecans, sweet onion marmalade, gorgonzola & fresh rosemary sm 9.40 | med 16.55 | lg 24.25

pasta dinners

served with dinner salad & garlic bread

diavolo mild, medium or spicy served with linguine 14.25 with shrimp 17.25 with chicken 16.75
tomato sauce with spaghetti or angel hair 13.25 with meatballs 15.75 with italian sausage 15.75
Stacks Image 94
meat sauce (above) with spaghetti or angel hair 14.25 with meatballs 16.75 with italian sausage 16.75
lasagna • meaty, beefy, big & bouncy 14.50
fettuccine alfredo 13.75 with chicken 16.25
Stacks Image 98
basil pesto (above) with linguine or fettuccine 13.75 with chicken 16.25
ravioli (5 jumbos) • beef with meat sauce 13.95 cheese or spinach with tomato sauce 13.25
chicken piccata • sautéed slices of chicken in a lemon butter sauce accented with capers & tossed in linguine 15.25
Stacks Image 102
rosemary cream chicken sautéed slices of chicken in a rosemary cream sauce accented with mushrooms & sun-dried tomatoes served on fettuccine 16.25
clam sauce red or white sauce tossed with linguine 15.25
shrimp santa cruz sweet, spicy, smoky & buttery served with angel hair 15.25
vodka cream sauce spicy & rewarding with penne or fettuccine 13.75 with chicken 16.25
pasta primavera classic fresh vegetable primavera on wheat penne 13.75 with chicken 16.25
quattro formaggio oven-baked penne with a blend of four cheeses & tomato sauce 13.75 with meat sauce 14.75 with spicy tomato cream sauce 14.75

Gluten-free pasta options are made with gluten-free spaghetti, additional $1.85

chicken dinners

served with dinner salad & garlic bread
Stacks Image 205
chicken marsala (above) oven-roasted chicken breasts in a marsala wine cream sauce with mushrooms, served over new potatoes 16.25
venezia chicken two chicken breasts crowned with baked ricotta, goat cheese & sun-dried tomatoes 16.25
chicken parmesan • chicken breasts baked with romano, parmesan, mozzarella & provolone 16.25


cut out the carbs and pack in the protein – served with dinner salad
Stacks Image 106
chicken torino (above) chicken breasts with pesto, monterey jack, toasted pecans, bacon & sautéed mushrooms 16.25
baked roman holiday two chicken breasts capped with thin canadian ham, alfredo sauce, provolone & bacon 16.25

calzones •

thin dough filled with good stuff, folded & baked
Stacks Image 110
make your own (above) our cheese blend with your choice of 3 toppings with pizza sauce 9.40 additional toppings extra
greek garden a delicious blend of spinach, red onion, black olives, tomato & feta cheese 9.40
meatball heaven hunks of meatball with mushrooms & gorgonzola cheese 9.40
queen of hearts marinated artichoke hearts in a delightful blend of ricotta cheese, tomatoes, mushrooms & spices 9.40
napoli sliced italian ham with roma tomato & provolone 9.40
bbq chix barbecue chicken with green peppers & smoked gouda 9.40
junior mozzarella, romano, provolone & fontina cheese 9.40
chicken bada bing sliced chicken breast baked with ricotta, goat cheese & sun-dried tomatoes 10.25


served with chips
Stacks Image 114
hot italian sub (above) salami, ham, tomato, pepperoni, banana peppers & italian dressing 8.95
sicilian sausage with roasted onions & peppers 8.95
meatball sub meatballs & marinara topped with cheese & fresh basil 8.95
ham & cheese italian ham, swiss cheese, a hint of bacon, tomatoes & our dijon vinaigrette dressing 8.95
chicken parmesan • big & brawny & delicious 10.25
spinach artichoke spinach, mushroom, red onion, tomato & artichoke spread 7.65 with chicken 10.75


Stacks Image 118
bruschetta (above) fresh tomato, garlic & herbs on toasted bread, with or without goat cheese 6.85
spinach artichoke dip a smiling teeth version of this classic 7.25
scamorza smoked mozzarella melted over tomatoes & herbs with toast for dipping 6.85
garlic bread • made with unsalted butter, olive oil & fresh minced garlic full order 4.75 half order 2.50
garlic bread with cheese • full order 6.00 half order 3.50
sun-dried tomato bread • rich flavor of sun-dried tomatoes, fine cheeses with tomato sauce & ranch for dipping 7.00
Stacks Image 122
pepperoni bread • (above) fine cheeses & pepperoni with a hint of buttery goodness, served with tomato sauce & ranch dressing for dipping 7.70
bread sticks • with ranch or tomato dipping sauce full order – six per order 5.00 half order 3.00 nacho cheese 1.25 extra
spicy meatballs for real spicy served with crostini for dipping 7.70


homemade dressings include italian, dijon vinaigrette, buttermilk herb (ranch), fat-free italian, (blue cheese or caesar 75¢ extra)... we also have fat-free french
Stacks Image 126
dinner salad mega abundant 5.95 with sliced chicken breast 8.45
antipasto fresh vegetables & cheese with pepperoni & italian ham served with our italian dressing 8.25
greek salad spinach, lettuce, red onions, black olives, tomato slices & feta cheese 7.30
caesar salad 6.25 with sliced chicken breast 8.75
bbq chicken • served with buttermilk herb dressing & crumbled blue cheese 8.95
spring mix served with pecans, candied cranberries, crumbled blue cheese & dijon vinaigrette 7.30 with chicken breast 9.80
puccini’s blue cheese wedge 7.00 with bacon 8.50


seasonal selections • bowl 5.25 | cup 4.25

desserts •

it’s ok... share!
Stacks Image 130
authentic carnegie deli cheesecake • 6.50
layer carrot cake • sweet & nicely balanced with cream cheese 6.30
chocolate torte flourless, gluten-free, rich & decadent 6.00
tiramisu • a perfect classic imported from italy 6.30
high 5 chocolate layer cake • five layers of intense goodness 6.85


large soft drink, lemonade, coffee, iced tea, hot tea, milk 3.50
bottled root beer 3.75
san pellegrino half liter 4.75
please ask your server for a beer & wine list or click here for a PDF of our current offerings.
we also offer rotating taps of local beers - come in and try something new!

kids’ menu

does not include salad, bread or drink
Stacks Image 134
ravioli (3 jumbos) • 4.50
fettuccine alfredo 5.80
spaghetti plain or w/butter 4.00
spaghetti w/tomato sauce 4.75
spaghetti w/meat sauce 5.25
small cheese pizza • 6.85
little hands plate black olives, cheese & crackers 4.25

lunch menu

served monday - friday during lunch hours only
Stacks Image 213

daily lunch special

slice, salad & drink lunch special choice of today’s pizza slices – always a meat topping, always a veggie – you get a large slice of pizza, a fresh garden salad with your choice of dressing and a large soft drink, all for only 9.40
pizza by the slice
every day you have two choices – always a meat & always a veggie 3.95
soup & salad bowl of soup with lunch salad 8.95
Stacks Image 279
Stacks Image 281
lunch salad fresh, delicious vegetables & cheeses served with your choice of our homemade dressings (see salad section for dressings) 4.95
lunch greek salad 6.30
angel hair or spaghetti with tomato sauce 8.95 with meat sauce 9.45 add a meatball 1.25 add italian sausage 1.25
fettuccine alfredo 11.00 with chicken 13.50
linguine or fettuccine with pesto or vodka sauce 9.45 with chicken 11.95
linguine with clam sauce white or red 11.95
jumbo ravioli (4 jumbos) • beef served with meat sauce 9.95 cheese or spinach served with tomato sauce 8.95

our meatballs and meat sauce are made with both beef and pork
18% gratuity added to tables of eight or more

Stacks Image 137

Want your own copy of the menu?

Download a PDF right here!